There’s something about a Reacher novel. That guy walking
across America, hitching, catching busses, drinking coffee in diners, never
washing his clothes, just buying new ones, encountering small towns run by bad
men, incompetent cops and over-confident tough guys. He goes into these mean towns
and isn’t himself mean. He uses his fists mostly, and elbows, and his simple
moral code, but he’ll pick up a gun if he needs it. He’s definitely not Tom
Cruise. He’s a young Clint Eastwood, or maybe Robert Mitchum. Who is he these
days? I’m not sure Hollywood actually produces men like that any more. Maybe
Matthew McConaughey, if he dialled it down quite a lot.
I read somewhere that Lee Child basically starts a story and
follows his nose, and sometimes it shows. The books can meander. I read one
where there was barely a fight in it and the story wandered around a bit
aimlessly till it ended. Not very satisfying. That gruff, matter-of-fact style
can suddenly look a bit exposed and ordinary if nothing much is happening. If
the momentum of the plot sags, then it can get boring. But mostly they work.
Take a clearly defined character, aim him at trouble, see what happens.
Genre is of course fluid, not clearly defined, but with
these books you know exactly where you are. No character development, no big
themes, nothing interesting going on with the language. Just Jack Reacher,
doing his thing.